I’ve done this twice before, and so wanted to try again to see how much AI has improved over the last two and a half years. My first attempt was in December 2022, and my second was in March 2023.
I gave ChatGPT 5.1 the following prompt:
Can you write me a short story that’s about your roommate is a hulking demon, a former warlord with millennia of combat experience, and the picture of menace and brutality. You just caught them halfway through a gallon-sized bucket of your favorite ice cream, frozen like a deer in headlights.
And credit where credit is due, this prompt is primarily from u/quazerflame on Reddit.
And here’s what it gave me back:
The apartment was quiet—too quiet for sharing a 900-square-foot unit with a seven-foot infernal warlord.
I nudged the door open and stepped inside. Boots in their usual pile. Smoke curling faintly from scorch marks in the drywall. A faint smell of brimstone and… was that vanilla bean?
Then I saw him.
Kharzug the Ever-Rending—slayer of empires, breaker of celestial armies, devourer of souls—was frozen in the middle of the kitchen like an overgrown gargoyle. His obsidian horns nearly scraped the track lighting. His four crimson eyes were wide and guilty. His massive clawed hands gripped a gallon-sized bucket of my ice cream, spoon halfway to his fanged mouth.
It was a tableau of pure, comedic betrayal.
“…Kharz,” I said slowly. “Is that my Triple-Chocolate Nebula Swirl?”
He didn’t move. Not even a twitch. If you’ve never seen a millennia-old demon react to being caught stealing dessert, imagine a tiger trying to pretend it’s a houseplant.
Finally, in a voice that once commanded legions of the damned, he rumbled, “THIS IS NOT WHAT IT APPEARS.”
I crossed my arms. “Really? Because it appears you’re halfway through a bucket that cost me twelve dollars and approximately one moral compromise.”
He lowered the spoon with a clatter. “I… was testing it. For poison.”
“It’s ice cream.”
“Poison can be creamy.”
“Poison cannot be creamy.”
His shoulders slumped, a boulder deflating. “Fine. I… craved sweetness. In the Pit, the only dessert was the tears of vanquished foes.” He stared down at the melting bucket. “This is better.”
Against my better judgment, sympathy poked me in the ribs. He’d saved my life twice this month—once from a cursed IKEA dresser, once from a malfunctioning air fryer. We weren’t friends exactly, but we were… roommates with occasional emotional nuance.
“Next time,” I said, taking the bucket gently from his claws, “ask.”
He looked genuinely confused. “You would… share this ambrosia?”
“Within limits.”
He knelt—knelt—on the tile, lowering his head. “Your mercy honors me.”
“Oh my god, get up,” I groaned, pushing his shoulder. “You’re not pledging fealty for ice cream.”
But he didn’t rise immediately. He looked at me with all four eyes, softer than I’d ever seen them. “In my world, sharing food means trust.”
I blinked. “Well… welcome to Earth, I guess. Here it means I get half the pint.”
He erupted into a gravelly laugh that shook the cabinets. “HALF! A worthy negotiation!”
I grabbed two spoons from the drawer, handed him one, and plopped onto the couch. The demon warlord sat beside me, legs tucked awkwardly, trying not to break the furniture.
Together, we finished the ice cream.
He cried a little.
I pretended not to notice.
I feel like the characterization, humour, and pacing feel so much better than the previous attempts. What do you think? Have we reached the point where AI can effectively write short stories? Have you tried to use AI to create anything? What was it and how well did it do?
We certainly live in interesting times. The ability for humans to steer different AI tools to do interesting things can be quite fun and easy. I definitely feel the lowering of value in various creative efforts due to AI both in and out of my work. It is amusing to me how little pushback there is in using AI to code but if you use AI to create images, video, audio, or text, then people stand up and push back. Why do you think that is?
Note, the image at the top of this post was generated by Midjourney.

Leave a comment